European Jewish Congress
The new definition of Antisemitism should be used to investigate Jenny Tonge
EJC in the Media
The new definition of Antisemitism should be used to investigate Jenny Tonge

Last week, the Community Security Trust released its annual report on hate crimes against Jews in 2016. It found a record high of antisemitic incidents in Britain, with no discernible reason for this spike. 

In response to the release of this report, Baroness Jenny Tonge asked rhetorically if it had been considered that hate crimes committed against Jews were because of Israeli government actions – and suggested that if the Jewish community spoke up against Israel it would lessen the amount of hate crimes.

This is hardly an aberrant comment from this source. In 2015, she tabled a written question in the House of Lords asking whether the British government would press Jewish “faith leaders” to condemn Israeli policy.

According to the definition of antisemitism officially adopted by the British Government in December last year, “Holding Jews collectively responsible for actions of the state of Israel” is a contemporary example of how antisemitism manifests itself in public life.

Theresa May said the aim was to “ensure that culprits will not be able to get away with being antisemitic because the term is ill-defined.” 

The necessity of an official definition is because, unique among all hate crimes, hate against Jews has largely been defined by the perpetrator and not the victim - in distinct opposition to the findings of the famous Stephen Lawrence Inquiry. The Macpherson Report specifically stated that the police are directed to investigate any incident that a victim believes to be racially motivated.

Tonge’s statement not only fits the newly adopted definition of antisemitism; she also singles out the Jewish people for her outrage.

In her long and dishonourable career in public life spanning almost four decades, Tonge has never blamed any other victims of hate crimes for their oppression.

It would be absurd to suggest that people of Iranian descent should be held responsible for the Islamic Republic’s hanging of gays, people in the Arabian Peninsula for the Saudi regime’s repression of women, religious and minority rights, or Chinese people living in Britain for the occupation and repression of Tibet.

However, Tonge has singled out one people for special treatment in the most despicable way, suggesting that unless they undergo some type of loyalty or ideological test they must be held responsible for any verbal or physical violence that is directed their way.

Her recent statement should serve as a test case for the legally adopted definition of antisemitism. It falls crudely but squarely under the definition and thus surely falls foul of Britain’s hate speech laws. 

Offences under these laws carry a harsh punishment of imprisonment or a fine, or both. According to the House of Lords Reform Act of 2014, a Lord could be automatically expelled from the House upon conviction for a serious criminal offence, if resulting in a jail sentence of at least one year. 

Pressing forward with steps against Tonge would send a very strong and robust message that the new definition of antisemitism has real meaning and significance and that nobody, regardless of position, is above the law, especially when it applies to hate against a group of people.

If a peer made hate comments against any other minority there would correctly be a national outcry for action, conviction and expulsion from parliament.

The law against hate speech should not create a two-tier system which holds hate against Jews to be qualitatively different from other forms of hate. 

If the British authorities really believe in quelling and acting against antisemitism, they should start with an investigation against Jenny Tonge, and send a strong message that 2017 will be the year that hate against Jews will no longer be held to a double-standard in the application of the law and the severity of the crime. 

Moshe Kantor is  president of the European Jewish Congress

Click here to read the full article in Jewish Chronicle

Friday, February 10, 2017
Subscribe to our Newsletter
Life in Israel
  • Israel and Palestinian Authority agree on historic water deal
    US Special Representative for International Negotiations Jason Greenblatt announced on Thursday that Israel and the Palestinians had reached an agreement concerning the long-discussed Red Sea-Dead Sea Canal, whereby Israel will each year sell 33 million cubic meters of water to the Palestinian Authority to relieve the water situation there.

    On Thursday, July 20, 2017 Israel and Palestinian Authority agree on historic water deal
  • Israel sets up plan to keep large tech firms ahead of the curve
    The Israel Innovation Authority is setting up a new programme to provide grants for research and development (R&D) at Israeli corporations that have annual sales of more than $100 million, in an effort to help them maintain a technological edge over competitors, undertake more daring projects by participating in the risk, and ensure their continued growth.

    On Thursday, July 20, 2017 Israel sets up plan to keep large tech firms ahead of the curve
  • India and Israel launch technology fund to prepare for digital age
    Israel and India launched a technology fund today aimed at growing the countries' business relationship and signed seven accords boosting cooperation in areas ranging from space research to water and agriculture.

    On Thursday, July 13, 2017 India and Israel launch technology fund to prepare for digital age
  • Israel rounds up traffic stopping stray camels
    Israeli government agencies on Sunday rounded up some 30 stray camels that were roaming near the road and posed a danger to drivers.

    On Thursday, July 13, 2017 Israel rounds up traffic stopping stray camels
  • Israel earmarks funds for special needs technology
    Apps that help children on the autistic spectrum and wheelchair users are among the projects that have received NIS 3 million in funding from the Israel Innovation Authority for the development of technological solutions for populations with special needs.

    On Thursday, July 13, 2017 Israel earmarks funds for special needs technology
  • Israel seeking Saudi flight deal to bring pilgrims to Mecca
    Israel is trying to persuade Saudi Arabia to allow it to send special Hajj pilgrimage flights to Mecca.

    On Thursday, July 13, 2017 Israel seeking Saudi flight deal to bring pilgrims to Mecca
  • Israel's Ben Gurion Airport places in world's top ten list
    Israel's Ben-Gurion Airport is the 8th best airport in the world, according to Travel + Leisure magazine readers.

    On Thursday, July 13, 2017 Israel's Ben Gurion Airport places in world's top ten list
  • First health clinic for African refugees opens in Jerusalem
    Jerusalem’s first medical clinic serving the city’s 3,000 uninsured African refugees and asylum-seekers from Eritrea, Sudan and Ethiopia opened this week to treat the largely marginalised and at-risk population.

    On Thursday, July 06, 2017 First health clinic for African refugees opens in Jerusalem
  • Health ministry recognises French medical degrees
    French organisations in Israel are applauding a Health Ministry decision to recognise French medical degrees, breaking down a significant barrier for immigrants.

    On Thursday, July 06, 2017 Health ministry recognises French medical degrees
  • New flower named in honour of visiting Indian prime minister
    Israeli Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu and visiting Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Tuesday stopped at a flower farm where a new strain of chrysanthemum was named in honour of the Indian leader.

    On Thursday, July 06, 2017 New flower named in honour of visiting Indian prime minister
President's Page Security and Crisis Centre by EJC European Parliament Working Group On Antisemitism